DEI in Higher Education

Publication Date: May 14, 2024

What is DEI?
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, commonly referred to as DEI, is a highly critical aspect of any organization; and DEI in education, specifically higher education, is especially important. DEI in higher education institutions encompasses the policies and practices designed to help ensure everyone in the institution, whether it is faculty, staff, or students, have equal opportunities for success and inclusion, no matter their background.
 
Understanding DEI
Diversity includes race, ethnicity, gender, religion, sexual orientation, geographical representation, and political beliefs, among many other factors. However, what diversity means varies amongst individuals. Studies have shown that race, gender, and sexual orientation are almost always the top three concerns for those working in the field, but inclusion is equally important.
 
DEI in Higher Education – why it’s important
Prioritizing DEI in higher education not only impacts students, faculty, and staff, but also the institution and entire campus. DEI provides advancement opportunities for underrepresented communities and comes into play when recruiting students, hiring faculty and staff, shaping campus culture, encouraging career advancement, setting up tenure processes, examining employment budgets, and making forward-looking decisions.
 
Benefits of DEI
DEI promotes personal growth, a healthy society, and fosters mutual respect and teamwork amongst the institution. DEI brings multiple perspectives and challenges stereotypical preconceptions, encourages problem-solving and critical thinking, and helps individuals learn how to communicate effectively with people of different backgrounds. Most importantly, DEI enriches the educational experience, as we learn from those whose experiences, beliefs, and perspectives are different from our own.
 
Why does DEI fail?
Although investing in DEI is never a waste of an institution’s time or resources, there are several reasons why DEI efforts are not as effective. Despite overwhelming evidence that institutions are becoming more demographically diverse, research has shown that more than half of employees feel excluded and isolated at work. Institutions with DEI initiatives are also experiencing employee fatigue because employees either feel exhausted, frustrated, or skeptical whether their DEI efforts provide expected tangible results.
Many employees are trying to improve DEI initiatives by starting either an employee resource group or a DEI Council to get things started. However, over time those same employees often end up feeling frustrated, burned out, and discouraged because they do not believe that their institution is equally invested and committed to advancing DEI due to lack of participation, support, and investment. Unfortunately, when employees feel their efforts are in vain, they eventually give up. This is especially difficult when management and those in leadership positions lack diversity and often underestimate and overlook the time, commitment, money, and effort needed to improve and sustain DEI.
 
How to build a more successful DEI strategy
For DEI initiatives and strategies to succeed, institutions need to set the tone at the top and have a top-down, systemic, business-led approach to demonstrate DEI is an essential part of the culture and institution. It is also imperative that institutions set clear, specific, and achievable goals, establish accessible protocols, build equity into the structure, and, most importantly, lead by example. Management and leadership need to take an active role in implementing initiatives and prioritizing DEI. This should not be the sole responsibility of the DEI employees.
 
What can Internal Audit do?
Internal Audit can get involved and support DEI initiatives by conducting DEI audits for their institution. The DEI audit will highlight how well the institution supports diverse and underrepresented employees and put a spotlight on areas where the institution is progressing, as well as identify issues and challenges that exist that need a little more attention. Having Internal Audit support DEI fosters an institution that embraces inclusivity, nurtures a sense of belonging, and amplifies opportunities for individuals from historically underrepresented backgrounds. Internal Audit’s strategic commitment aids in creating a stronger institution that thrives on a diverse array of perspectives and experiences. DEI audits are an opportunity to dig beneath the surface and reflect on the institution’s own priorities and goals. DEI audits are critical tools that, when done properly and consistently, can be a real advocate for institutional change.
 
Because DEI success does not happen overnight, creating a diverse, equitable, and inclusive institution is a continual process; one that requires constant growth from all levels: individual to the institute.
 
Editor’s Note: The ACUA DEI committee plans to send a survey to its members in the coming months. Your participation is greatly encouraged.